What a New Home in London, Ohio Costs Once It's Built

Two houses on Maddoxx Drive in London Landing at Brooksedge are built from the same floor plan. Both are the Palmetto, a two-story Arbor Homes design with four bedrooms, 2.5 baths and 2,580 square feet. The one at 223 Maddoxx Drive is listed at $379,999. A few lots away, 231 Maddoxx Drive is listed at $419,990.

Arbor's plan page lists the Palmetto from $342,990. Those three numbers belong to one house design, and the spread between the lowest and highest is $77,000. The house at 231 Maddoxx has a full basement with an egress window and 9-foot basement ceilings. The one at 223 has a brick elevation and a 2-foot garage extension.

That spread matters most if you're choosing between a new home and an existing one in London. The "from" prices in London's three active new-home communities all fall at or below what homes in the area have been selling for. Once a house is finished and listed, the price moves up to meet the market. To compare new and resale fairly, set a finished home's price against what existing homes are actually selling for. The base price on a brochure doesn't belong in that comparison.

Base price and finished price, side by side

Arbor Homes has finished homes listed in both of its London communities, and each one can be matched to the starting price of a plan with the same square footage. The table uses Arbor's own published figures. Builder pricing changes often, so treat them as a snapshot.

Community Plan size Advertised starting price Finished home listed Difference
Madison Reserve, Arrival Series 1,428 sq ft, 3 bed $251,990 325 Legacy Lane, $279,270 $27,280
London Landing at Brooksedge 1,228 sq ft, 3 bed $277,990 201 Maddoxx Drive, $299,999 $22,009
London Landing at Brooksedge 1,760 sq ft, 3 bed $312,990 229 Maddoxx Drive, $339,990 $27,000
London Landing at Brooksedge 2,580 sq ft, 4 bed $342,990 223 and 231 Maddoxx Drive, $379,999 and $419,990 $37,009 to $77,000

D.R. Horton's Johnson's Creek works differently. The plan prices there move in a tighter band. The 2,053-square-foot Bellamy starts in the $367s, and the finished 2,053-square-foot home at 1234 Stratford Way is listed at $399,900. The plan that starts highest in the $395s is 2,618 square feet. Of the two finished homes that size, 1159 Stratford Way is listed at $404,900 and 1191 Stratford Way at $389,900, just under the plan's starting figure. Johnson's Creek's six finished homes are listed between $389,900 and $416,487, while the community advertises homes from $348,990.

In London Landing, the finished homes run $22,000 or more above the starting price for the same size. Every one of Johnson's Creek's six finished homes is listed above $389,000.

Where the finished prices land against London's sales

Columbus REALTORS reports London through the London City School District. According to its October 2026 Local Market Update, in October 2026 that area had 16 closed sales at a median price of $365,182, up 23.8% from $295,000 in October 2025. From January through October 2026, the median was $330,000, up from $258,000 over the same months of 2025.

Set the finished homes against that $330,000 year-to-date median. The 1,228-square-foot home at 201 Maddoxx sits below it. The 1,760-square-foot home at 229 Maddoxx sits within about $10,000 of it. Every finished Palmetto and every finished Johnson's Creek home sits above it. The finished homes that land under the local median are the smallest ones: 201 Maddoxx and the Madison Reserve home at 325 Legacy Lane, in the community the city's mayor described as priced for teachers, young professionals and first-time buyers.

Price per square foot shows why the base prices look low. The Palmetto's starting price works out to about $133 a square foot. The finished homes at 223 and 231 Maddoxx come to about $147 and $163. In October 2026, homes sold across the London City School District averaged $204 a square foot, and $192.96 for January through October. The larger new floor plans still come in under that average on a per-foot basis, even finished. The per-foot cost rises as the plans get smaller. The finished 1,428-square-foot home at 325 Legacy Lane works out to about $196 a square foot, and Madison Reserve's 1,159-square-foot Coach starts at $239,990, or about $207 a square foot, before any options.

What October's resale numbers say about room to negotiate

The existing-home side of London was firm this fall. In October 2026, sellers in the London City School District received 99.8% of their original list price on average, up from 92.6% in October 2025. Homes took 32 days to sell, the same as a year earlier.

Supply loosened a little. The district had 39 homes for sale at the end of October, up from 34 a year earlier, which works out to 2.5 months of supply, up from 2.2. The Madison County report for the same month shows the county as a whole with 2.8 months of supply and a $400,000 October median, so London's school-district area ran slightly tighter and less expensive than the county overall.

Monthly figures here come from small numbers of sales. September 2026 had 16 closed sales at a $308,000 median, and a month later the median was $365,182. One or two larger homes can move a month's number that far, which is why the year-to-date $330,000 is the steadier benchmark. Columbus REALTORS also notes that its price figures don't account for sale concessions.

Builders, meanwhile, are advertising financing offers. Arbor's London Landing listings display a "4.99% / 5.752% Special Offer." D.R. Horton's page lists a 3.99% rate on a 5/1 FHA adjustable-rate mortgage, 6.329% APR, with 3.5% down and a required 1.125% discount point. The offer applies to contracts signed on or after October 23, 2026, that close by December 31, 2026, and only to certain homes in select Ohio communities. These are the builders' advertised terms as of November 2026. This post is general information, not financial advice, so please confirm any financing with your own lender before you rely on it.

On a resale home this fall, London sellers were getting close to full asking price. On a finished new home, the list price is often above the local median, but the builder may be advertising a lower rate alongside it.

More finished homes are coming

London's builders aren't close to done, and that affects both sides of the comparison. In a December 2025 interview with Business View Magazine, Mayor Patrick Closser said London Landing has 266 homes planned, with roughly 170 finished at that point. He also said "Homes started in the high 200s and are now selling around $370,000." Madison Reserve has 240 homes planned.

Johnson's Creek is the largest project. Its developer described a 159-home first phase and 872 homes in total, on land between Amherst and Chevington, Keny Boulevard and State Route 38, according to an update London Elementary School shared in January 2025. M/I Homes, the second builder there, lists its Johnson's Creek section as coming soon, from the low $400s, with basements included. In the same Business View Magazine interview, the mayor said London had joined the Mid-Ohio Water and Sewer District and was putting $20 million to $30 million into a sewer expansion to support housing growth.

That makes London very different from Plain City, where new-home supply is waiting on a regional sewer line. In London, new homes will keep coming onto the market on a steady schedule. A buyer weighing a resale home this winter will keep seeing finished new homes listed nearby, at prices above the base figures. A seller listing an existing three- or four-bedroom home will be compared against those same finished prices. The October median list price of new listings in the London City School District was $299,900, below the month's $365,182 sale median. Many existing London homes come to market priced under the finished new homes nearby.

A few practical points for your comparison:

  • Arbor's availability notes for upcoming homes give only a month, such as "Available in December" for 229 Maddoxx Drive and "Available in February" for 325 Legacy Lane. Ask for a move-in date in writing.
  • Johnson's Creek lists an HOA among its amenities. Ask for the current dues for any community before you compare monthly costs.
  • Price a resale home against a finished new home of the same size, and count the basement, brick elevation and garage options the finished new home already includes.

If you're weighing a finished home on Maddoxx Drive against an existing house across town, let's talk through how the two compare, finished price to finished price. Reach out to Keli Fisher, visit the London neighborhood page, or, if you already own in London and want to know where your home stands against these new listings, Get Your Instant Home Valuation at kelifisher.com/home-valuation.

Work With Keli

If you’re looking for a real estate professional who combines expertise with a personal touch, I’d love to help you turn your real estate dreams into reality. Let’s make your next move your best move!

Let's Connect